The Catholic Church holds that the last days began with Christ,
not in 1914, and not on any other date a calculation might
produce. This is not a Catholic peculiarity but the plain and
repeated statement of the New Testament, made by writers who
located themselves inside those days rather than looking forward to
them. Once that is seen, the question is no longer when the last
days will start, but what it means to be living in them.
The Last Days Began in the First Century
The first Christians did not invent the phrase. They inherited it
from the prophets, and then announced something startling: the
long-awaited age to come had already dawned, because the Messiah
had come, the Spirit had been poured out, and the new covenant
had been sealed in His blood.
They say so repeatedly and without hedging. Hebrews opens:
“in many and various ways God spoke of old to our fathers by
the prophets; but in these last days he has spoken to us
by a Son” (Heb. 1:1–2). Peter writes that Christ
“was made manifest in the last times for your
sake” (1 Pet. 1:20). John tells his readers, “it
is the last hour” (1 John 2:18). And Paul
says of his own generation that “these things … were
written down for our instruction,
upon whom the end of the ages has come”
(1 Cor. 10:11), where the Greek verb is a perfect, denoting
an arrival already complete.1
The clearest declaration comes at Pentecost. When the Spirit falls
and the crowd is bewildered, Peter stands and explains:
“this is what was spoken by the prophet Joel:
‘and in the last days it shall be, God declares, that I will
pour out my Spirit upon all flesh’” (Acts 2:16–17).
This is that. Peter tells the assembled crowd that they
are standing in the last days the prophets foretold, not centuries
off, but in the outpouring they are watching. The gift of the
Spirit is itself the proof that the final age has begun.2
Two texts the Watchtower itself leans on say the same. Paul’s
description of “the last days,” with its lovers of self
and money and pleasure (2 Tim. 3:1–5), ends with the
instruction “Avoid such people” — counsel that is
useless unless such people stood in Timothy’s own
congregation. And Jesus told His hearers that some standing before
Him would not taste death before they saw the kingdom of God come
with power (Mark 9:1) — which fits a kingdom inaugurated in
their generation, in the Resurrection, Pentecost and the
gospel’s spread, and does not fit one established in 1914,
long after every one of them had died.
A Witness will reply that the New Testament’s last days were
the last days of the Jewish system, or of the apostolic era, while
1914 opened “the last days of this system of things”
— a different period. The distinction should be met, not
brushed past. The phrase can be applied to more than one ending,
and the first-century usage alone does not disprove 1914. What it
does is shift the burden: if Scripture already locates the last
days in the age Christ opened, a second, dated set of last days
needs a warrant of its own, and the only warrant offered is the
chronology examined below — not any text that names a later
period.
The text usually named is Luke 21:24, “until the times of
the Gentiles are fulfilled,” read as the 2,520 years ending
in 1914. But Luke gives the phrase a subject and an object:
Jerusalem “will be trodden down by the Gentiles” until
those times end. It describes the city’s subjection, not a
heavenly enthronement, and it names no number; the years come from
Daniel 4, which does not mention the Gentiles at all. A text that
says nothing of 1914 cannot be the warrant for it.
Two Ages, and the Overlap
Behind the phrase lies a structure the first Christians took over
from Judaism: this age, marked by sin and death, and
the age to come, marked by resurrection and the reign
of God. The Jewish expectation was that one would simply succeed
the other at the Messiah’s arrival.3
What the apostles proclaimed was stranger and better. The age to
come had already broken into this one. The decisive turn had
already occurred, in the death and resurrection of Christ, and
the two ages now overlap. The Christian lives in that
overlap: really in the new age, since the Spirit is given and sins
forgiven and the Kingdom entered; still in the old, since death
and sin persist and the final consummation awaits. This is what
theologians call the already and the not yet, and it explains why
the New Testament can speak of Christians as already raised with
Christ and still awaiting the resurrection without contradiction.4
The Kingdom belongs to that same pattern. Christ said it had
already come upon His hearers (Matt. 12:28; Luke 17:21), and Paul
says of living Christians that God “has delivered us from
the dominion of darkness and transferred us to the kingdom of his
beloved Son” (Col. 1:13), a past tense, written eighteen
centuries before the Kingdom is said to have been born.5
Where the Date Comes From
Set against all this is a chronology that needs analysis. The 1914
date rests on the
“seven times”
of Daniel 4, a passage about the madness and recovery of
Nebuchadnezzar, in which nothing is said of Gentile times, of
2,520 years, or of any date whatever. The seven times are converted
to 2,520 years by treating each “time” as 360 days and
each day as a year, then counted from a date for Jerusalem’s
fall that secular chronology does not support. Every step requires
an assumption the text does not supply.6
The method’s own history is the strongest comment on it.
The Watchtower’s earlier calculations yielded 1799 for the beginning of the last days and 1874 for Christ’s return, and
those dates were taught into the 1930s before being replaced. A
calculation that has already produced two abandoned answers is not
made reliable by producing a third.7
The expectations, in order — each from the Society’s own publications:8
- 1799 — the “last days” begin (taught into the 1930s).
- 1874 — Christ returns invisibly (taught into the 1930s).
- 1914 — first expected as the end of earthly rulership; recast, after it passed, as an invisible enthronement.
- 1925 — Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob expected back on earth (“Millions Now Living Will Never Die”).
- 1943 — Christ’s return re-dated from 1874 to 1914.
- 1975 — six thousand years of human history to end; families praised for selling their homes to pioneer “the short time remaining.”
- 1995 — “this generation” of 1914 redefined: no longer the people alive in that year.
- 2010 — redefined again: two “overlapping” groups of anointed.
Vigilance, Not Calculation
What Christ actually said about dating is unambiguous, and He said
it in the middle of the very discourse from which such predictions
are built: “But of that day and hour no one knows, not even
the angels of heaven, nor the Son, but the Father only”
(Matt. 24:36). After the resurrection the disciples asked directly
whether He would now restore the kingdom, and He refused the
question: “it is not for you to know times or seasons which
the Father has fixed by his own authority” (Acts 1:7).9
What He called for was not calculation but readiness. Watch,
therefore, because you do not know. The whole point of the parables
of the returning master, the wise and foolish virgins, and the
thief in the night is that the hour is not disclosed, and
that a servant who needs to know the date in order to behave has
misunderstood the command. A teaching that supplies a date removes
the very uncertainty that vigilance depends on.
The composite “sign” fares no better, and Christ
Himself is the one who blunted it. Wars and rumors of wars, He
said, must come, “but the end is not yet”; famines
and earthquakes are “but the beginning of the
birth-pangs” (Matt. 24:6–8). He offered these not as
a calendar but as a caution against being misled by them —
they are what every generation sees, which is why every
generation since has found them abundantly. A sign present in
all ages marks out none. And the presence it is said to signal
invisibly is, in the same discourse, as unmistakable as
lightning shining from east to west (Matt. 24:27).
What the Church Requires
It is worth saying what the Catholic Church does not do
here, because the contrast is part of the argument. She holds that
Christ will return, that the dead will rise, that there will be a
judgment, and that the Kingdom will be consummated. She has never
defined a date, a timetable, or a scheme for reading current
events as prophecy, and she has consistently discouraged the
attempt. The Christian is left where the New Testament leaves him:
in the last days already, awaiting a day nobody knows, and told to
be ready for it now.10
This is the short answer. The full
treatment adds the two-age schema set out in detail with its
Jewish sources and its Christian transformation, the parousia
and what the word meant in the first century, Augustine on the
millennium and how the Catholic tradition reads Revelation 20,
the history of the Watchtower’s dates from 1799 onward with
the publications that carried them, what the Church has and has
not defined about the last things, and full documentation for
everything asserted here. It is available as a Word document at
the end of this page.
Endnotes
- Hebrews 1:1–2; 1 Peter 1:20; 1 John 2:18; 1 Corinthians 10:11, where katēntēken is perfect, denoting a completed arrival whose effects continue. See also Acts 2:17; Hebrews 9:26 (“at the end of the age”); 1 Peter 4:7. ↩
- Acts 2:14–21, citing Joel 2:28–32. Peter’s “this is what was spoken” identifies the event before him with the prophecy, and the prophecy locates itself “in the last days.” ↩
- On the two ages in Second Temple Judaism, 4 Ezra 7:50 (“the Most High has made not one world but two”) and 6:7–10, where the age to come follows this age as Jacob’s hand followed Esau’s heel, with nothing between; 2 Baruch 44:8–15; and, among the rabbis, m. Avot 4:16 (“this world is like a vestibule before the world to come”). That Judaism expected the one age simply to succeed the other, whereas the New Testament sets the two overlapping, is the point classically made by George Eldon Ladd, The Presence of the Future (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1974), ch. 3, and A Theology of the New Testament, rev. ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1993), part 1. ↩
- On the two ages, see Matthew 12:32; Mark 10:30; Ephesians 1:21. On the overlap, Romans 6:4–11 and Colossians 3:1–4, where believers are already raised with Christ and still await the appearing. ↩
- Matthew 12:28; Luke 17:20–21; Colossians 1:13, where the verb is aorist. The nature of the Kingdom is treated on the companion page What Is the Kingdom of God? ↩
- Daniel 4 concerns Nebuchadnezzar’s madness and restoration; the chapter mentions neither Gentile times nor any span of years. The 2,520-year figure is obtained by treating the seven times as prophetic years of 360 days and applying a day-for-a-year principle drawn from other passages, then counting from a date for the fall of Jerusalem which standard Neo-Babylonian chronology does not support. ↩
- The Society formerly taught that the last days began in 1799 and that Christ returned invisibly in 1874, holding both into the 1930s before replacing them with 1914. See C. T. Russell, Studies in the Scriptures, vol. 2, The Time Is at Hand (1889), and vol. 3, Thy Kingdom Come (1891); the history is summarized in Jehovah’s Witnesses—Proclaimers of God’s Kingdom (1993), pp. 132–138. ↩
- In order: note 6 above for 1799 and 1874; C. T. Russell, The Time Is at Hand (1889), on 1914 as the end of the kingdoms of this world; Millions Now Living Will Never Die (1920) on 1925; The Truth Shall Make You Free (1943), re-dating the presence to 1914; Life Everlasting in Freedom of the Sons of God (1966): “six thousand years from man’s creation will end in 1975”; Kingdom Ministry, May 1974, p. 3, on “brothers selling their homes and property” to serve in “the short time remaining before the wicked world’s end”; The Watchtower, November 1, 1995, and April 15, 2010, on the successive redefinitions of “this generation.” ↩
- Matthew 24:36, with Mark 13:32; Acts 1:6–7. On vigilance rather than calculation, Matthew 24:42–51; 25:1–13; 1 Thessalonians 5:1–6. ↩
- Catechism of the Catholic Church §§668–682 on the Kingdom and the last things, and §676 on the Church’s rejection of attempts to realize the Kingdom within history by human calculation or effort. ↩